Archive for the ‘Top story of the day’ Category

Toledo dog fight, shooting bring anger, sorrow and fear

Sunday, June 7th, 2015
2015.0606.matiff.missy.todd.camping

Missy a purebred mastiff being treated for a shotgun wound to her face is shown resting on the shoulders of Todd Jewett, one of her owners, during a fall camping trip. / Courtesy photo

By Sharyn  L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

The rescue puppy Mary Fairbanks acquired five years ago grew up to be 114 pounds of dog she describes as a “petite” mastiff.

It and its companion, a black Labrador retriever, were being taken care of by a house sitter while the Toledo resident and her fiancé were out of town, visiting a new grand-baby when they got the phone call.

Their neighbor had shot Missy the mastiff with a 12-gauge shotgun, Fairbanks said. “The whole left side of her face was blown off.”

As the phone got traded around, through several conversations including with a deputy sheriff who responded to the scene along Herifford Road and Shoreline Drive, Fairbanks learned Missy somehow got out of their fenced yard, went next door and tangled with the neighbor’s German shepherd.

2015.0601.missy.mastiff.injured.smaller

Missy, after she was rushed to a veterinary hospital.

The neighbor Douglas Bramhall told the deputy they’d gotten their pet safely inside and he went outside twice, the second time carrying his gun out his back door.

She learned Bramhall said her dog lunged at him, and he fired once, then her dog ran home bleeding.

Fairbanks, who said veterinarians refer to the large breed dogs as “gentle giants” found the neighbor’s story unbelievable.

Missy is a dog who children could lay on, who greeted numerous contractors over the past couple of months at their new home without a hint of aggression, and got along with other animals, according to Fairbanks.

“We lived for two and a half years on five acres in Tenino, with no fences and no issues,” she said. “Our dogs visited our neighbor’s dogs.

“There’s just so much more to this, we just don’t understand.”

Most upsetting, was trying to figure out why the neighbor went back outside if he thought he was putting himself in harm’s way.

“He’s in his house with his door shut,” Fairbanks said. “If she’s this horrible mean dog, why’d he go back out?”

That was last Sunday morning. By Thursday, Missy had undergone surgery at a veterinary hospital in Tacoma, and had a surprisingly good prognosis.

“What saved her is she’s young, she’s healthy, and strong,” Fairbanks said.

The vet picked what Fairbanks called pellets out of her face, leaving in the ones they couldn’t get to, she said. A feeding tube is getting installed, that Missy will have for at least six weeks.

“As long as no infection sets in, she’ll make it,” she said.

Fairbanks had endless questions, such as did the Bramhall’s dog, whose customary bathroom spot is property now inhabited by strangers, antagonize Missy.

The Lewis County Sheriff’s Office investigated and a spokesperson said they didn’t expect any charges on either side.

Both parties were talking about suing each other, however.

“The law is, you have a right to protect your life and property,” Chief Deputy Stacy Brown said on Friday. “People can armchair quarterback it, but the investigation shows it was a justifiable shooting at this point.”

As for Missy’s owner, Lewis County has an ordinance that addresses “prohibited activities of animals”, such as biting or threatening others as well as “animals at large” that prohibits dogs from roaming off their own property. Civil infractions can be issued, but in this case it seemed clear it was an accident when Missy got out of her fenced yard, according to Brown.

The deputy’s report indicates the house sitter inadvertently left the gate to the backyard open while watering plants.

“I think this is an unfortunate situation for everyone involved,” Brown said. “The learning point is, even if you live in the country, you have to keep your dogs on your property. Because if they get out, unfortunate things can happen.”

Further, Brown said, dog owners often will say their animal never behaved badly before, but dogs act differently when they are under the control of their owner.

Fairbanks and her fiancé Todd Jewett moved to Lewis County in early April. The property was vacant before they constructed the shop building where they reside until they can get a house built.

Bramhall meanwhile, is upset too.

The 56-year-old said he knew the new neighbors had dogs and was surprised to come home late one night and learn that while he was out, his 14-year-old son had opened their front door because the mastiff and their German shepherd were fighting on his porch.

“My dog had some bite marks and came in and laid down,” he said. “My son got the door shut before the mastiff got in here.”

He thought it was odd, because the neighbor’s dogs were always penned up, he said. Jewett had cautioned him though, he said, that he needed to watch out for the big one, Missy.

Bramhall said he and his wife talked, and thought maybe the next day, he needed to talk with Jewett.

“We wake up on Sunday morning, about 8:30, and all of the sudden on the front porch, there’s a commotion again,” he said.

He said the mastiff was out there, fighting with his dog and when his wife opened the door, their dog came in and the mastiff tried to follow it.

He tried to open the door to holler at the dog and it continued trying to get inside, he said.

“I went out the back door, yelling, ‘Todd, Todd, get over here’,” he said.

The mastiff heard him and came around the house, barking and snarling, he said. He slammed the door.

Bramhall said he grabbed his mole gun for protection, and went out the back again, because he wanted to get a hold of Jewett.

“(She) makes a lunge, I pull the trigger,” he said. “I was point blank when I shot the thing.”

Bramhall said he told his wife to call the sheriff.

He still sees the glazed eyes, and the snapping jaws on a head the size of a pumpkin, he said.

“One of us was gonna wind up hurt, me or the dog,” he said.

Bramhall said the deputy came and he gave his statement.

“He calls the people, tells them the story, I’m feeling bad,” he said. “I have animals. I’m an animal person. I go out of my way for animals.”

The Bramhall’s dog, Zena, escaped with nicks on her neck and ears, and some on her leg, according to Bramhall.

It’s sad it went down the way it did, he said, but it wasn’t out of mean spiritedness or anything of the sort.

“If I was vindictive, I’d have grabbed a gun that would have killed it,” he said.

In Lewis County, when an animal kills livestock, or bites or is acting aggressive, deputies forward the case to the code enforcement department for review. Another portion of the county ordinance on animals has provisions for a civil process by which a dog can be labeled dangerous, and then various requirements will kick in, according to Bill Teitzel.

Teitzel, a supervisor at Lewis County Public Health, said he looked over the deputy’s report and concluded Missy’s actions met the definition of a potentially dangerous dog.

“It’s really a warning,” Teitzel said, noting that if something happens again, the animal is flagged.

Before the weekend began, the two couples met and came to agreement it was a tragedy that shouldn’t have happened.

“We exchanged hugs, we exchanged tears,” Fairbanks said in a phone message on Friday. “We exchanged words of what we all did wrong in the situation, and what we could have done better.”

They want to put it behind them, she said, especially in light of Bramhall receiving numerous threats since a graphic photo of the injuries appeared on a Go Fund Me page, and other social media.

“That’s not what we want,” Fairbanks said.

Bramhall echoed her sentiment.

“These people are grieving, and I feel their grief,” Bramhall said. “Nobody’s happy it happened.”

They talked about what they could have done to prevent it, he said.

“They realize they should have taken the time to introduce their pets,” Bramhall said. “I’m thinking about what I could have done different.”

While Fairbanks and Jewett spoke of how much he’ll love Missy when she comes home and they introduce the two properly, Bramhall said he’s not sure he wants to meet the dog.

“I’m just scared,” he confessed.

He said he plans to invest in an electric fence for his property.

•••

Read the Lewis County ordinance regarding animals, here

Faked will case gets Centralia dad less than two years incarceration

Wednesday, June 3rd, 2015

By Sharyn  L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

CHEHALIS – The Centralia father of three who took over the assets of a deceased man claiming to be a relative will go to prison, despite his lawyer’s appeal to the judge to give him a drug offender sentencing alternative.

Michael J. Dobbs, 47, pleaded guilty to first-degree theft and to forgery, in connection with a case that began to unfold last autumn.

2015.0409.dobbs.smaller.7391

Michael J. Dobbs

Chehalis police were contacted by the family of Walter Pettit who went to Pettit’s house near Chehalis Middle School and found it had been ransacked. Detectives learned Pettit, 55, had died months earlier at a hospital in Thurston County.

Dobbs produced a will making him the sole heir of the estate, but the dead man’s purported signature didn’t match his handwriting, and his name was misspelled, according to prosecutors.

Defense attorney Michael Underwood told the sentencing judge yesterday that arrangements had been made for his client to picked up from the jail and go directly into long term inpatient drug treatment, and after that, he would continue to get care at the Veteran’s Hospital in American Lake.

“If he doesn’t complete it, he has all this time hanging over his head, and will go to prison,” Underwood said.

The defendant, when asked if he had anything to say on his own behalf told the judge that if he got locked up, his children would get put into the foster care system and be split up.

“It’s been 22 years, and I’ve yet to get treatment for my addiction, and I have an opportunity now,” Dobbs said. “It’s time for me to change, I’ve been doing this for too long, and I’m tired of it.”

Lewis County Deputy Prosecutor Eric Eisenberg said he had proposed if Dobbs spoke candidly with the detective about the location of the stolen property for the family and about other people involved, he’d accept Dobbs’ letter expressing Dobbs’ desire to better himself, for his children.

But he felt he still needed to recommend prison time, Eisenberg said.

The offense is a property crime, but it’s different, the deputy prosecutor said.

“One of the items stolen was literally the ashes of Walter Pettit,” he said. “The dignity he should have for his burial, the family’s not going to be able to get that back.”

Gary Ford was somber when he the told court his thoughts on the matter.

“My half brother is dead,” Ford said. “He struggled his whole life, but was a wonderful person who would do anything for anyone.”

Ford said he didn’t want any restitution, he’d rather the judge impose extra time instead.

He and his wife were going to bury his half brother with his mother, he said.

“But that’s not going to happen,” he said.

Lewis County Superior Court Judge Richard Brosey didn’t take long to make a decision. It was one of the more outrageous and egregious crimes he’d seen in awhile, he said.

“It’s one thing to steal from somebody,” Brosey said. “But taking family heirlooms warrants time in state prison.”

Brosey sentenced Dobbs for three separate offenses, with the time running concurrently.

For the theft, he gave him the top of the standard range of 18 months in prison. For the forgery, he gave him 12 months. And for a bail jumping charge that came about related to a methamphetamine possession conviction during the investigation, he gave him 22 months.
•••

For background, read “Centralia man charged with stealing dead man’s estate by faking a will” from Saturday April 11, 2015, here

Chehalis ATM shakedown case ends with prison for one, jail for other

Wednesday, June 3rd, 2015

By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

CHEHALIS – The 18-year-old Chehalis man who admitted he was driving the getaway car when an acquaintance robbed a woman at the TwinStar Credit Union’s ATM machine in March was sentenced today to nine months in jail.

James M. Rocha offered an apology in court, on behalf of his family and the victim.

2015.0409.james.rocha.7396

James M. Rocha

“I am guilty of driving the vehicle,” Rocha said. “And I am guilty of having the suspicion something was going on.”

Rocha pleaded guilty to second-degree robbery, as an accomplice.

Prosecutors lowered the charge from first-degree robbery and agreed to recommend nine months in jail in exchange for his plea.

Lewis County Superior Court Judge Nelson Hunt went along with it this afternoon.

The victim had gone to the 1500 block of South Market Boulevard in Chehalis to deposit a check in the ATM at about 9:15 p.m. on March 26. A male wearing a black bandana over his face approached her and told her to “empty all your cash,” but when she said she had none, he demanded her cell phone, which she turned over, according to police and court documents. The 42-year-old woman was unhurt.

2015.0410.andre.santiago.7402

Andre F. Santiago

Witnesses in the area recognized the small reddish car and one of them took down its license plate as it sped away. Police first contacted Rocha at his home in the same end of town. Police were also able to “ping” the stolen cell phone.

The 20-year-old friend, Andres F. Santiago, turned himself in about two weeks after the incident and told police he’d forced Rocha and their 15-year-old companion to drive him around that night, and they hadn’t done anything wrong.

Santiago, also from Chehalis, had gotten himself into inpatient treatment to get help with drug addiction, and was working with Cascade Mental Health when he contacted police to confess.

He pleaded guilty as charged – to first-degree robbery – a week and a half ago, and was sentenced to three years in prison.

Santiago had no criminal history. Rocha had a juvenile felony from four years prior.

Lewis County Senior Deputy Prosecutor Will Halstead said the 15-year-old boy who was with them that night was not charged with a crime, as he was asleep in the back seat of the car.
•••

For background, read “Three arrested in connection with Chehalis ATM shakedown” from Friday April 10, 2015, here

Sledge hammer to face incident draws serious charges

Tuesday, June 2nd, 2015

By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

CHEHALIS – The 59-year-old Centralia man arrested after reportedly shattering his neighbor’s nose with a small sledge hammer told police the neighbor swung the hammer at him first, according to court documents.

The dispute at the 1300 block of Central Boulevard on Sunday night arose out of the victim playing his music too loud, according to authorities.

2015.0601.Morris.R.Keith.Jr.incourt7571

Morris R. Keith Jr. is seated for his bail hearing.

Morris R. Keith Jr. was arrested and then charged yesterday with second-degree assault, first-degree burglary – because police say the assault took place in the victim’s garage – and also felony harassment based on a witness reporting Keith said during the argument he was going to kill them.

According to charging documents, when police responded to the north Centralia neighborhood they found Justin Moon screaming someone had broken his nose.

A witness, Kimberly Brooks, told Officer Angie Humphrey that Keith arrived carrying the hammer, that he thought Moon’s music was too loud and said he didn’t like Moon’s “Ni**er* rapping music.”

Brooks told the officer Keith hit Moon in the crotch with it and the argument continued, according to the documents. She said Keith was screaming and hit Moon in the face with it.

Keith had dropped the sledge hammer and left, according to Brooks, but his wife came over and took it away.

When Officer Humphrey spoke to Keith, he said the hammer was Moon’s, and that Moon swung it at him first.

Charging documents don’t recount any of what Moon may have said to his neighbor. Humphrey noted he smelled of intoxicants.

Moon was taken to Providence Centralia Hospital with what was described as a “flattened” nose. The doctor at the emergency room said it was the worst broken nose he’d ever seen.

Felony harassment has a maximum penalty of five years in prison, second-degree assault can bring 10 years and first-degree burglary carries a top sentence of life.

A judge yesterday in Lewis County Superior Court set Keith’s bail at $25,000. His arraignment is set for Thursday.
•••

For background, read “News brief: Loud neighbor music leads to sledge hammer attack” from Monday June 1, 2015, here

Drive-by shooting charges filed against two Centralia men

Tuesday, June 2nd, 2015

By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

CHEHALIS – Two Centralia men are each charged with one count of drive-by shooting and one count of second-degree assault after an incident one of them said was a joke gone bad and the other denies involvement in.

Edward A. Butterworth, 29, and Ronald L. Orr, 26, were arrested at a dead end road in what the sheriff’s office called a felony stop early Saturday morning after a report someone fired several shots outside a home east of Centralia and then took off in a dark sport utility vehicle.

2015.0601.ronald.orrincourt7570

Ronald L. Orr – accused of firing several shots from a vehicle – waits to be returned to the jail after his bail is set at $150,000.

The Lewis County Sheriff’s Office initially described the incident as two guys who thought it would be funny to scare guests at a friend’s birthday party by driving by his home on the 1700 block of Big Hanaford Road and firing several shots from a 22 caliber pistol.

Chief Deputy Stacy Brown said those involved were friends.

Charging documents state that Butterworth told deputies he’s good friends with the neighbor Thomas Denegar and had been invited to his party, and that he and Orr were at Butterworth’s home across the street and then decided to play a joke.

The documents give the following account of what Butterworth said happened: They pulled into Denegar’s driveway and shined a light into the residence.

Then they pulled down the road by a barn and Orr fired a 22 pistol into the brush several times.

As they drove down Big Hanaford Road, Butterworth saw David Brosius’ vehicle behind them and knew Denegar was with him.

Orr thought it would be funny to scare them again and fired more shots from his pistol out the passenger window, according to Butterworth.

The vehicle behind them backed off, Butterworth said.

The documents give the following account of what Brosius and Denegar, both 28 years old, told deputies: They were at Denegar’s home when they saw a light shining into the residence so they went outside. They heard a vehicle and approximately five shots.

“Brosius stated they all went to the ground out of fear of being shot,” the documents relate.

The two got in Brosius’ vehicle and followed, and as they approached Teitzel Road, they saw the passenger lean out the window and fire several more shots.

“Brosius stated it appeared the shots were being fired directly at them by the way the muzzle flashed,” the documents state. They backed off.

Law enforcement officers found three fired 22 caliber casings in the roadway on the 400 block of Big Hanford Road, and one on the edge of the roadway near the barn as Butterworth had described, according to the documents.

A search of the vehicle turned up a Ruger 22/45 pistol, a rifle and a revolver. The Ruger had a .22 caliber round in the chamber.

When the two were questioned, Butterworth stated they knew they screwed up. Orr told deputies they were sitting outside Butterworth’s house when they heard the shots, and they got in a vehicle to go investigate. Orr denied ever shooting a firearm from the vehicle. They were booked into jail.

When the two arrestees were brought before a judge yesterday afternoon, lawyers noted neither has any felony criminal history.

Defense attorney Joely O’Rourke said she understood one of the alleged victims didn’t want Butterworth prosecuted and reached out to him offering to take care of his home and his dog.

Judge James Lawler set his bail at $100,000. He set Orr’s bail at $150,000.

O’Rourke noted that the two work at the same place, but the judge signed a no contact order between them.

The offenses they are charged with each carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison and a $20,000 fine.

Their arraignments are scheduled for Thursday in Lewis County Superior Court.
•••

For background, read “News brief: Prank with gun not so funny” from Monday June 1, 2015, here

Chehalis, Centralia introduce new public safety leaders

Sunday, May 31st, 2015

By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

CHEHALIS – The city of Chehalis welcomed its new fire chief and the city of Centralia its new police chief last week, as both were sworn in at their respective city council meetings.

The two men had already been on the job a week.

Ken Cardinale was sworn in late Tuesday afternoon and shared a few words with city leaders of the county seat.

2015.0526.cardinale.mcbeth.7539

New Chehalis Fire Chief Ken Cardinale is sworn in by Chehalis Municipal Court Judge Dale McBeth.

“What I’ve gotten to know so far is what a great group of firefighters and captains I’m leading,” Cardinale said. “They are true professionals that go above and beyond every day.

The Kelso resident who most recently spent 29 years with the Palo Alto (California) Fire Department, introduced his wife Beth Cardinale after she pinned on his badge.

“We’re glad to have you aboard, and hit the ground running,” Chehalis Mayor Dennis Dawes said.

Cardinale met with three neighboring police chiefs earlier in the day, to talk about how they could work more together.

He said he comes from a place with a more regional approach, and therefore many more resources.

Already he has submitted a draft plan to his boss to start a student firefighter program, something he said he’s a product of himself.

“If that goes well, we could look at resuming the reserve program,” Cardinale said.

The new chief takes over a department that has been led by interim chiefs for the past 12 months, and by a half-time chief for the year before that.

Later on Tuesday evening, Carl Nielsen was sworn in as the new chief of police in neighboring Centralia, the county’s most populous city.

2015.0526.nielsen.buzzard.7546

New Centralia Police Chief Carl Nielsen is sworn in Centralia Municipal Court Judge James Buzzard.

Nielsen whose most recent position was second in command at the Turlock Police Department in California’s central valley thanked outgoing Police Chief Bob Berg, the city manager and the city council for entrusting him with the department.

His wife Jan Nielsen pinned his badge on him and was introduced, along with others in the audience including his mother, one daughter, mother-in-law and her friend as well as a new neighbor who all attended the ceremony.

He took extra time to thank Berg who had spent the previous several days helping him get acquainted.

Berg’s love and passion for the department will be his legacy, Nielsen said as he wished him well in retirement.

Centralia’s new police chief also read aloud the law enforcement code of ethics, the version adopted by the International Chiefs of Police.

A version of it is included in the department’s policy manual, and he intends to include it in swearing in ceremonies for new officers.

Here it is:

“I Carl Nielsen, subscribe as follows:

As a Law Enforcement Officer, my fundamental duty is to serve mankind; to safeguard lives and property; to protect the innocent against deception, the weak against oppression or intimidation, and the peaceful against violence or disorder; and to respect the Constitutional right of all men to liberty, equality and justice.

I will keep my private life unsullied as an example to all; maintain courageous calm in the face of danger, scorn, or ridicule; develop self-restraint; and be constantly mindful of the welfare of others.  Honest in thought and deed in both my personal and official life, I will be exemplary in obeying the laws of the land and the regulations of my department.  Whatever I see or hear of a confidential nature or that is confided to me in my official capacity will be kept ever secret unless revelation is necessary in the performance of my duty.

I will never act officiously or permit personal feelings, prejudices, animosities or friendship to influence my decisions.  With no compromise for crime and with relentless prosecution of criminals, I will enforce the law courteously and appropriately without fear or favor, malice or ill will, never employing unnecessary force or violence and never accepting gratuities.

I recognize the badge of my office as a symbol of public faith, and I accept it as a public trust to be held so long as I am true to the ethics of the police service.  I will constantly strive to achieve these objectives and ideals, dedicating myself before God to my chosen profession … law enforcement.”
•••

For background, read:

• “News brief: Chehalis picks new fire chief” from Monday April 27, 2015, here

• “News brief: Centralia picks new police chief” from Friday April 10, 2015, here

Missing person found dead in Chehalis River

Saturday, May 30th, 2015

Updated

By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter

Firefighters responded to a report of a drowning this morning, at Fort Borst Park where police looking for a missing 23-year-old man found the victim floating face down in the Chehalis River along the bank, according to Riverside Fire Authority.

The fire department reports the body was confirmed to be the missing individual who they describe as having an extensive history of autism.

The fire department was on the scene at the Centralia park shortly after 7:30 a.m.

Centralia police reported later the deceased as 26 years old.

Just after 7 o’clock this morning, police were dispatched to a missing person complaint at the the 2000 block of Borst Avenue, according to the Centralia Police Department.

A short time later, an officer located the body of the male in the river, near where it meets with the park’s pond, according to detective Patty Finch.

The department is investigating the details surrounding his death, Finch said.

Exactly who he was with or what he was doing at the park isn’t yet clear, Finch said.

The detective said it was the Centralia man’s mother who reported him missing, but they don’t know if she was with him at the park. Detectives have been trying to locate several people to talk to, she said.

Finch said he is someone she has not met personally, but understands the level of his disorder was such that he was supervised, or should have been supervised, at all times.

His name isn’t being released, but is expected to be released later by the Lewis County Coroner’s Office. Police are hoping an autopsy will be performed on Monday or Tuesday.

The 2000 block of Borst Avenue is the stretch that runs behind the Harrison Avenue Safeway, from Interstate 5 to Johnson Road.