
Elijah M. Garibay, 25, of Elma, consults with defense attorney Bob Schroeter in Lewis County Superior Court during his bail hearing.
By Sharyn L. Decker
Lewis County Sirens news reporter
CHEHALIS – The victim of a beating that led to a nighttime police search through a Centralia neighborhood for suspects was a key witness in a trial that ended earlier this week in the conviction of a fellow heroin user.
Thomas Pennypacker, 32, of Chehalis, testified against Lonzo Lawson who was sentenced to more than eight years for breaking into a Napavine bar and stealing almost $15,000.
But that’s not what prosecutors think necessarily specifically led to the events on Tuesday night in the parking lot of the Peppertree Motel on Alder Street.
“I’m inclined to believe this is related to other individuals,” Lewis County Deputy Prosecutor Shane O’Rourke told a judge.
The suspects allegedly called Pennypacker a snitch and said they were going to kill him as he was choked, repeatedly shocked with a stun gun and punched in the face. He escaped the car he had arrived in with the men and ran to the motel office for help, according to charging documents. The car sped away and two of the three men from it were captured in the area within the next hour and a half, according to police.
The Centralia Police Department initially said the victim was with the subjects because he was trying to buy heroin.
O’Rourke said it looked like a beating under the guise of a drug deal. “A pick ’em up payback kind of thing,” he said.
He wouldn’t confirm if Pennypacker was one of law enforcement’s so-called confidential informants, drug case defendants that can get certain plea deals if they cooperate with police in setting up drug dealers.
“All I can say is he is involved in cases with the state,” O’Rourke said yesterday afternoon, noting the recent trial.
Yesterday in Lewis County Superior Court, two of the three suspects were charged with multiple offenses including intimidating a witness. Judge Richard Brosey ordered them held on $250,000 bail pending their trials.
Joseph M. Hanks, 30, is from Rochester. He was described by Pennypacker as “somewhat of a friend” who picked him up Tuesday night because they were going to buy some heroin.
Elijah M. Garibay, 25, has an Elma address listed as his residence in court documents.
Pennypacker indicated in the documents he didn’t know Garibay, that he was just one of two men Hanks unexpectedly picked up as they were driving to get drugs.
Charging documents give the following account:
A Centralia officer interviewed Pennypacker at the hospital where he was being treated for his injuries, which included Taser injuries along his face and shoulder.
Pennypacker told the officer he hadn’t known anyone else was coming with him and Hanks, and it concerned him when the two men were picked up.
He said after they arrived at the Alder Street motel, he handed $60 to Hanks, who gave it to one of the passengers. That man got out and almost immediately Garibay who was in the backseat put his arm around Pennypacker’s throat and began strangling him. Then Garibay began Tasing him in the face and side.
Hanks got out and began punching Pennypacker in the face full force, he said.
That’s when they called him a snitch and said they would kill him. Then he fled to the motel office and they sped away in Hanks’ Honda.
Motel manager Kaitlin Mendonca, in her vehicle, chased the car to the nearby dead end of Long Road, where they got out and left on foot.
The 25-year-old said today she wasn’t really sure what she was doing, but wasn’t going to let them just drive away.
Court documents indicate Hanks was spotted in a field and turned himself over to officers.
Later in the night, law enforcement was advised a resident few blocks to the north was holding at gunpoint a suspicious male discovered in a yard.
Dan Henderson, 44, and a Centralia city council member, turned the man – who was Garibay – over to arriving officers. Some of his clothing he had allegedly shed was found nearby.
Police said yesterday no heroin was found when the car was searched. Police did find a stun gun, drug paraphernalia and small plastic bags, among other things, according to charging documents.
It’s not clear who the third suspect is, but charging documents for Garibay and Hanks which describe the evening’s events don’t mention the third man assaulting the victim.
Garibay and Hanks are each charged with intimidating a witness, second-degree assault, second-degree robbery and harassment.
Garibay’s prior convictions include one felony and 11 misdemeanors. Hanks’ include five felonies and 20 misdemeanors.
Their arraignments are scheduled for June 27.
•••
For background read:
• “Attempted drug deal turns violent in Centralia” from Wednesday June 19, 2013, here
• “Lawyers: Who broke into the safe at Frosty’s tavern?” from Wednesday June 12, 2013, here